The Goa Human Rights Commission has ruled that withholding a pension and attempting coercive recovery of past salary overpayments from a retired civil servant is arbitrary, illegal and a violation of human rights. The GHRC has directed state authorities to release all pending pensionary dues to the retired Senior Scale Officer, Shripad Arlekar, with 6% simple interest per annum, within 30 days.

A complaint was filed with the GHRC on June 15, 2026, by Shripad S. Arlekar, a resident of Malim Betim. Arlekar joined government service on August 30, 1988, and retired as a Senior Scale Officer of the Goa Civil Service on November 30, 2025.

After his retirement, the Directorate of Accounts issued a revised pay-fixation statement dated May 4, 2026, claiming that Arlekar had been granted an extra increment that had been erroneously applied from October 1, 2014, to November 30, 2025. Citing this administrative miscalculation, the state withheld his retirement benefits and sought to recover the alleged excess payments made over the 11-year period.
Arlekar was also denied even a provisional pension for more than eight months after his retirement, in apparent violation of the CCS (Pension) Rules.

Appearing in person, Arlekar argued that attempting to recover funds after his retirement for an administrative oversight—where no fraud or misrepresentation occurred on his part—contravenes established Supreme Court precedent.

The Directorate of Accounts contended that, because an excess payment had occurred, the state was entitled to recover the sum from Arlekar’s retirement benefits.

Rejecting the state’s position, the GHRC relied on landmark Supreme Court rulings and observed that the law bars back-recovery of excess payments from retired employees when the overpayment resulted from an administrative error or an incorrect interpretation of rules by the authorities, rather than from deceit or misrepresentation by the employee.

The GHRC further noted that the Government of Goa had endorsed these Supreme Court guidelines in Finance Department office memoranda dated March 7, 2017, and September 8, 2021. The commission observed: “The respondent authorities cannot be permitted to take advantage of their own administrative lapse to the prejudice of the complainant. In the facts of the present case, the respondents’ action is arbitrary, inequitable and unsustainable in law.”

Concluding that the failure to follow Supreme Court directives and official government memoranda violated Arlekar’s human rights, the GHRC directed the Directorate (Administration) of Health Services and the Directorate of Accounts to immediately release all pensionary and post-retirement benefits due from December 1, 2025, based on the corrected pay-fixation statement, without deducting any alleged past overpayments. The GHRC further ordered that all pending amounts be paid within 30 days, together with 6% simple interest per annum calculated from December 1, 2025, until the date of actual payment.