The High Court has acquitted Parsappa Kormal, who was earlier convicted by the Children’s Court in a 2017 case under the Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, holding that the prosecution had failed to prove his guilt beyond reasonable doubt. The High Court quashed the judgment dated December 7, 2018, read with the order dated January 10, 2019, passed by the Goa Children’s Court.

The case concerned an alleged incident on July 17, 2017, involving a child aged about 9–10 years. According to the prosecution, the child had gone to fetch buttermilk and was allegedly taken to a cowshed, where she was sexually assaulted.

The complaint was lodged the same evening after the child allegedly informed her mother. The police registered an FIR, and the child was medically examined the following day.
The prosecution relied primarily on the testimony of the child victim, supported by the evidence of her mother, medical evidence, and forensic reports.

The Children’s Court convicted the appellant, relying on the victim’s testimony and the medical findings.

In a 49-page judgment, the High Court re-appreciated the entire evidence and held that the Children’s Court’s assessment of the evidence suffered from “perversity and illegality.”

Defence counsel Adv. Esha Ghodekar highlighted several key infirmities, including material contradictions in the child’s testimony.

The High Court also found that the victim’s version in court contained several improvements and omissions when compared with her earlier statement recorded before the Magistrate.

These concerned material details about what allegedly happened at the spot, who was present, and what happened afterwards. The Court held that these were not minor discrepancies or ordinary lapses of memory, but went to the foundation of the prosecution’s case.
The prosecution had relied on the presence of human semen in the child’s mouth swab to connect the appellant to the crime.

The High Court rejected this argument, holding that there was no material to establish that the semen belonged to the appellant. No DNA profiling or comparison had been placed on record to link it to him. The Court observed: “The presence of human semen… is insufficient to establish a connection with the Accused in the absence of material indicating that the semen is of the Appellant.”

Acquitting the accused, the High Court held that the prosecution had failed to establish the foundational facts. Therefore, the presumption stood rebutted. Invoking the principle of dubio pro reo—that, in case of doubt, the benefit goes to the accused—the Court said there was a clear distinction between “might have committed” and “must have committed.” “Suspicion is not a substitute for proof,” the judgment stated.